| Sue Stednitz | |
|---|---|
| 1982 | All-Around |
| Balance Beam | |
| Elaine Alfano | |
| 1982 | Vault |
| 1983 | Vault |
| 1985 | Vault |
| Megan McCunniff (Marsden) | |
| 1983 | All-Around |
| 1984 | All-Around |
| Vault | |
| Lisa Mitzel | |
| 1985 | Floor Exercise |
| Missy Marlowe | |
| 1991 | Balance Beam |
| 1992 | All-Around |
| Uneven Bars | |
| Balance Beam | |
| Floor Exercise | |
| Kristen Kenoyer | |
| 1992 | Vault |
| Sandy Woolsey | |
| 1994 | Uneven Bars |
| Summer Reid | |
| 1996 | Balance Beam |
| 1997 | Balance Beam |
| Angie Leonard | |
| 1999 | Uneven Bars |
| Theresa Kulikowski | |
| 1999 | All-Around |
| Balance Beam | |
| 2001 | Balance Beam |
| Kristina Baskett | |
| 2006 | Uneven Bars |
| Ashley Postell | |
| 2007 | Balance Beam |
| Georgia Dabritz | |
| 2015 | Uneven Bars |
| MyKayla Skinner | |
| 2017 | Floor Exercise |
| 2018 | Vault |
| Maile O'Keefe | |
| 2021 | Bars |
| Floor | |
Sue Stednitz
1982
Elaine Alfano
1982, 1983, 1985
Megan McCunniff
1983, 1984
Lisa Mitzel
1985
Missy Marlowe
1991, 1992
Kristen Kenoyer
1992
Sandy Woolsey
1994
Summer Reid
1996, 1997
Angie Leonard
1999
Theresa Kulikowski
1999, 2001
Kristina Baskett
2006
Ashley Postell
2007
Georgia Dabritz
2015
MyKayla Skinner
2017, 2018
Maile O'Keefe
2021
| 26 (13 RS) | MyKayla Skinner |
| 20* | Ashley Postell |
| 16 (8 RS) | Georgia Dabritz |
| 16 | Kristen Kenoyer |
| 14 | Theresa Kulikowski |
| 13 | Amy Trepanier |
| 12 | Kristina Baskett |
| 12 | Missy Marlowe |
| 12 | Megan McCunniff (Marsden) |
| 11 | Melissa Vituj |
| 10 | Suzanne Metz |
| 9 | Shannon Bowles |
| 9 | Linda Kardos |
| 9 (5 RS) | MaKenna Merrell-Giles |
| 8 | Daria Bijak |
| 8 | Annabeth Eberle |
| 8 | Nicolle Ford |
| 8 | Lynne Lederer |
| 8 (1 RS) | Corrie Lothrop |
| 7 (4 RS) | Maile O'Keefe |
| 7 | Shelly Schaerrer |
| 7 (5 RS) | Tory Wilson |
| 6 | Deidra Graham |
| 6 | Denise Jones |
| 6 | Lisa Mitzel |
| 6 (2 RS) | Baely Rowe |
| 5 | Elaine Alfano |
| 5 | Megan Caudle |
| 5 (2 RS) | Nancy Damianova |
| 5 (4 RS) | Breanna Hughes |
| 5 | Angie Leonard |
| 5 | Stephanie McAllister |
| 5 | Tracy Richard |
| 5 | Sandy Woolsey |
| 4 | Christa Canary |
| 4 | Jamie Deetscreek |
| 4 | Eileen Huck |
| 4 (3 RS) | Cristal Isa |
| 4 | Veronique LeClerc |
| 4 | Summer Reid |
| 4 (2 RS) | Sydney Soloski |
| 4 | Traci Sommer |
| 4 | Sue Stednitz |
| 4 (2 RS) | Becky Tutka |
| 4 | Cheryl Weatherstone |
| 3 (2 RS) | Kailah Delaney |
| 3 | Diane Ellingson |
| 3 | Nina Kim |
| 3 | Meredith King |
| 3 (1 RS) | Kari Lee |
| 3 | Sandy Sobotka |
| 3 | Missy Wells |
| 3 | Kelli Wolsey |
| 2 | Annie DiLuzio |
| 2 | Jenny Donaldson |
| 2 | Tina Hermann |
| 2 | Gritt Hofmann |
| 2 | Kassandra Lopez |
| 2 | Patti Massoels |
| 2 | Molly Northrop |
| 2 | Sarah Northrop |
| 2 (2 RS) | Abby Paulson |
| 2 | Kristy Pinnick |
| 2 | Kristen Riffanacht |
| 2 | Kyndal Robarts |
| 2 | Angelika Schatton |
| 2 | Jessica Smith |
| 2 (2 RS) | Kim Tessen |
| 2 | Rachel Tidd |
| 2 | Theresa Wolf |
| 1 | Kim Allan |
| 1 (1 RS) | Alexia Burch |
| 1 | Shannon Coleman |
| 1 | Lia Del Priore |
Ashley Postell
| 1 | Jessica Duke |
| 1 | Alysa Frenz |
| 1 | Hailee Hansen |
| 1 | Celeste Harrington |
| 1 | Ashley Kever |
| 1 | Emilie LeBlanc |
| 1 | Tiffani Lewis |
| 1 | Mary Beth Lofgren |
| 1 | Lisa McVay |
| 1 | Samantha Partyka |
| 1 | Missy Reinstadtler |
| 1 | Beth Rizzo |
| 1 | Jenny Schmidt |
| 1 | Sabrina Schwab |
| 1 | Maddy Stover |
| 1 | Jill Stuart |
| 1 | Kris Takahashi |
| 1 | Kylee Wagner |
Note: Total includes NCAA Championships and Regular Season
*Record for NCAA Championships’ All-America awards (and the most possible)
(RS)=Regular Season All-American (began in 2013)